Ashley John Crowder, 36, is accused of murdering 37-year-old Graham Cox at Barton Walk in Farnworth at some point before March 5, 2024 and of repeatedly stealing from him and assaulting him.
A trial that opened this week at Bolton Crown Court, more than two years after Mr Cox was found dead, heard how he had been in a “pitiful state” in the time leading up to his death.
Mukul Chawla KC, prosecuting, said: “The murder occurred in the days before Graham Cox’s body was discovered on the evening of March 5.
“He had been beaten and there were fractures of the laryngeal cartilages in the neck.”
The trial opened at Bolton Crown Court (Image: Phil Taylor)
He added: “The prosecution say that Mr Crowder beat and strangled Mr Cox to death.”
Mr Chawla said it had not been possible to establish the exact time of Mr Cox’s death but that it had happened at some point before March 5, 2024.
Mr Chawla told the jury of seven men and seven women that Mr Cox had been “extremely vulnerable”, because of his long-term drug use and from strokes he suffered in 2023.
Police on the scene around Barton Walk (Image: Newsquest)
He told jurors that Crowder had access to Mr Cox’s bank cards and phone and so was able to take money from him in the period leading up to the 37-year-old’s death.
Mr Chawla said: “The thefts alleged are that this defendant stole money from Mr Cox.
“Not in the usual way perhaps by picking his pocket or by taking his wallet but, by forcing Mr Cox to pass all the money that he received as benefits from the Department of Work and Pensions to the defendant when Mr Cox was, as you will see, in desperate need of it.”
Crowder, who wore a teal and blue North Face top and black trousers, listened from the dock as Mr Chawla told the court he had assaulted Mr Cox on February 22, just weeks before his death.
Officers investigating around Barton Walk in Farnworth (Image: Newsquest)
He said Mr Cox was left with bruising to his face and arms and that he had “suffered a beating” that damaged his ribs.
Jurors heard how on March 5 that year a woman called 999 and told the police she believed there was a dead man at a flat on Barton Walk.
On arriving, officers were let into Crowder’s flat by the defendant himself who told them “What it is, my mate’s passed away.
“I was about to phone the ambulance, I’ve just gone and checked on him, do you want to come in?”
A murder investigation was launched after Mr Cox was found dead (Image: Newsquest)
Mr Chawla said that Crowder told the officers Mr Cox had suffered a blood clot after hitting his head on a cabinet and that he had been “looking after him for four weeks”.
Crowder was arrested on suspicion of assault shortly after Mr Cox was formally pronounced dead and just after midnight that night was rearrested on suspicion of murder.
On being interviewed Crowder refused to answer most of the questions put to him but made it clear that Mr Cox had not been “locked in the flat” and had been able to leave if he wanted to.
But Mr Chawla told the jury that the investigation uncovered a “history of profound physical and financial abuse of Mr Cox by the defendant”.
Mr Chawla said: “The prosecution say that it is clear that Graham Cox had been fearful of the defendant for some considerable time.”
He told the jury that Mr Cox had made several complaints about Crowder over the last six months of 2023, not to the police but to medical professionals.
In one such case Mr Cox stayed over at hospital where a ward sister said that he told her that over the past 10 weeks a “friend” had stolen his bank card to buy drugs.
Mr Cox also told the nurse that this “friend” had taken the keys to his house, had been attacking him and that he was afraid to contact the police because he was fearful about “retaliation”.
Mr Chawla said it was clear that Crowder did in fact have Mr Cox’s bank cards during this time, including messages to his mother saying: “I’ve got Graham’s cards and phone”.
Later, on August 16 that year, before being discharged from hospital Mr Cox told an occupational therapist that he had previously agreed to move in with a “friend”.
But things “very quickly turned sour” and this man was a heavy drug user who was often involved in physical attacks.
Mr Cox told the occupational therapist that before coming to hospital he was “being chased with a knife and was fearful for his life”.
Mr Chawla said on October 26, Mr Cox showed a healthcare assistant text he had received saying “words to the effect like ‘you will get me the money today’ and ‘don’t f*** me over.’”
He told jurors how while staying at Royal Bolton Hospital Mr Cox “pleaded” with the healthcare assistant not to let Crowder into the ward to see him.
Crowder, of Barton Walk, Farnworth, denies murder, the alternative count of manslaughter, assault and four counts of theft.
The trial, before the Honorary Recorder for Bolton Judge Nicholas Clarke KC, continues.
You must be logged in to post a comment Login