A man who stole Noah Donohoe’s missing laptop has denied that it is his hand in a picture discovered on the schoolboy’s phone after he was last seen.
Daryl Paul told Belfast Coroner’s Court that he had “never set eyes” on Noah and insisted under questioning that he had never been in possession of his green coat or phone.
The inquest into the death of the schoolboy, which is being heard before a jury, is now in its 13th week.
Noah, a pupil at St Malachy’s College, was 14 when his naked body was found in a storm drain tunnel in North Belfast on June 27 2020, six days after leaving home on his bike to meet two friends in the Cavehill area of the city.
A post-mortem examination found the likely cause of death was drowning.
Noah’s mother Fiona Donohoe has attended every day of the long-running proceedings.
Paul, of Cliftonville Avenue, previously pleaded guilty to stealing a rucksack containing Noah’s laptop and books. He resumed giving evidence on Monday when he was questioned by Brenda Campbell KC, who represents Ms Donohoe.
Pointing out that Paul had previously lied under police questioning, the barrister said there were aspects of his possession of Noah’s belongings that “call for questions to be asked”.
The jury was shown CCTV footage of Paul in the Queen’s Quarter area of Belfast, close to Noah’s Fitzroy Avenue home, from the evening the schoolboy disappeared.
Paul said he had been in the area to see Maria Nolan, who he said he had recently met, and who has previously given evidence at the inquest.
Ms Campbell said: “On those occasions when you hung outside Queen’s Quarter like this afternoon, do you think you would have seen Noah? Did you speak to him?”
Paul replied: “No, never.”
She asked him if he had any knowledge of Noah leaving his home for a short period on the night before he disappeared.
Paul said: “I don’t know a single thing and if I did I would be the first to tell you, I have a heart.”
The jury was then shown CCTV footage of Noah cycling past Paul in Queen’s Quarter, wearing his green coat and carrying his rucksack.
Ms Campbell said: “This is the last time he leaves home, and you’re within a matter of metres of him.”
She pointed out that within an hour, Noah’s rucksack ended up in a green bag Paul is seen carrying in the footage.
The witness said: “I have no knowledge of that wee boy passing me.”
The barrister said: “What I want to explore on behalf of Noah’s mother is this series of coincidences, to understand whether they are coincidences or whether there’s reason to be more concerned.”
Ms Campbell continued: “Did you look in the direction of Noah after he went past?”
Paul responded: “I did. Just a natural thing, I guess.”
Ms Campbell said Paul had then travelled towards Royal Avenue in Belfast city centre while showing the jury a map of the route Noah cycled through the city.
Paul said: “I was only on same path as Noah for a short distance.”
The barrister said Paul had claimed during an interview with a journalist that he had found Noah’s rucksack containing his laptop on the ground in a covered walkway in the York Street/Frederick Street area.
The jury was shown footage of Noah cycling past that area without stopping.
Ms Campbell said: “I am going to suggest where you told the journalist that you found Noah’s bag is not where it was… you are wrong about that.”
Paul said: “I can only tell you where I found it. If I lied about that, what significance would that lie hold?”
Ms Campbell said: “Until this point in time we have got the coincidence of you being outside Queen’s Quarter and now the coincidence of you being on that part of his journey.
“But the coincidences, I am going to suggest, don’t stop there.”
The barrister said the jury had previously heard evidence about an anonymous caller to police who stated Paul had been in possession of Noah’s green coat.
Paul said: “I was not in possession of any green coat.”
She said: “It would be another coincidence upon coincidence?”
He said: “I did not have his coat.”
The barrister asked the witness if he had next “followed Noah’s journey” from the city centre along North Queen Street.
He said he had not.
She continued: “To the location where the phone was found?”
Paul said: “No.”
Ms Campbell said: “Do you know anything about Noah’s phone? Did you have it in your hand? Did you find it in his coat pocket or in his rucksack?
He answered: “No.”
The barrister said a report from a police expert had revealed a photograph of a hand on Noah’s phone taken on the evening he disappeared, 40 minutes after he was last seen.
She said: “Is that your hand?”
Paul responded: “No, it is not my hand.”
The barrister said police arrested Paul later on the same day but he was never asked where he had found the laptop or about the green coat.
She then showed the jury phone records from Noah’s phone on the day he disappeared.
Ms Campbell said Noah’s mother Fiona had called her son’s mobile six times on the evening he went missing.
She said: “Whoever had Noah’s phone in their hand at 18.50 would have a phone with six missed calls from ‘Mum’.”
The jury was then shown a map of the area in north Belfast where the phone was when Ms Donohoe sent a text message to her son on June 21 2020.
She said Victoria Parade, where Paul said he had gone after leaving Frederick Street, was within the area of the map.
She said: “Did you have Noah’s phone?”
Paul said: “No, I did not.”
Ms Campbell continued: “Did you see that message coming in and those phone calls?”
He said: “I don’t appreciate that question, but the answer is no.”
She said: “It is not too late to tell the truth, not too late to give him some justice.”
He responded: “Thank you, but no.”
Ms Campbell added: “Was it you who went along North Queen Street and who chucked his phone over the railings into Castleton Park?”
He said: “I wasn’t even there.”
She said: “You realised this was a phone that was a bit hot, there was a mummy desperate to find her child?”
Paul said: “No.”
The inquest continues.
For all the latest news, visit the Belfast Live homepage here and sign up to our daily newsletter.




You must be logged in to post a comment Login